Babylist Baby Registry Review - Baby Chick
Subscribe Search

Babylist Baby Registry Review

Finding the right baby registry can be overwhelming. To narrow it down for you, here's our baby registry review of Babylist and what you need to know.

Published August 12, 2022

This article may contain affiliate links. These opinions are our own. If you buy something, we may earn a small commission, helping us keep our content free to our readers. ❤️

Ah, the baby registry. This can be one of your favorite parts of pregnancy or one you dread. Some people love shopping around at different stores and have a registry here and one there, while others dread it. If you are the latter, then we have a solution for you. Enter Babylist, the one site you need to bring all your registries together and help score your gift-givers the best deals. Here is our review of the Babylist registry.

How Does Babylist Work?

Babylist Registry homescreen

Creating a Babylist registry is simple. You follow a few prompts and answer a few questions, and you are good to go. You don’t need to enter all your information, like shipping address and phone number, to get started. This is a nice feature because it allows you to do what you want, shop! So, let’s get down to it.

Babylist will enable you to create one concise registry with gifts from your favorite stores, including buybuy BABY, Target, Walmart, Amazon, and even Etsy and the Babylist online store. When people want to shop your registries, they only have to come to one place, and it is all there for them — pretty cool stuff.

How Do You Start Your Babylist Registry?

First, you have to add the Babylist bookmark to your browser. This is how you add items to your registry. Here is the fun part: the shopping! Let’s say you want to start your shopping at Target. Find something you like, click “add to Babylist” or the heart on the bookmark, make sure it has the image you want and the correct price, select what category you want it under, and then click “add to Babylist.” It is now on your registry! It’s super simple and fun to do.

Babylist Baby Registry Review

You can register at big box stores and online retailers and support local and small businesses by clicking on their websites and adding gifts to your registry. It is a fantastic way to support friends and family if they own businesses.

You can also start a Babylist registry on their Android and IOS apps. This registry option is just as simple. Download the app and create or log in to your web-based account. You will find several options at the bottom of the app, including an “add items” button. Once you tap that option, major retailers will come up, and you can begin shopping and adding to your registry, just as you would on your computer.

Babylist Baby Registry Review

Additionally, there is a link to the Babylist store that you can shop from at ease. The Babylist app allows you to share to Babylist, which lets you build your registry with your browser, just as you would online. It is simple to use and makes shopping a breeze.

Perks of Babylist

Hello Baby Box

Babylist Hello Baby Box

Babylist has a Hello Baby Box to give you an awesome gift when you register. There are a couple of steps, and you must register for three items on Babylist’s website and three items on another site. You have to purchase $10 and pay the shipping fee for the box. It’s a fun way to kick-start your registry and get a look at some hot baby items. You never know; you might find your favorite baby item in the box —worth the minimal work you must do.

15% Discount

Babylist Baby Registry Review

Babylist wants to ensure you get everything you need and want from your registry. Babylist offers a 15% discount for any remaining items in the Babylist shop on your registry for 60 days after your baby’s expected arrival to make registry completion more affordable. This is a great way to get all the must-have baby items and save money simultaneously!

Register from Anywhere!

Babylist Baby Registry Review

Babylist lets you list any item from any store to your registry. That means all the biggest names to your tiniest local boutique with your favorite swaddle blankets. It is all fair game and can be added to your Babylist registry. This makes it super easy to personalize your registry and find the things you really want for your baby.

The Pros

Babylist Baby Registry Review
  1. You can choose from thousands of items to add to your Babylist registry. You just add the bookmark add-in or use the Android or iPhone apps. Shop and click, and you are on your way to building a custom registry from all kinds of retailers.
  2. You can also shop directly from Babylist, which has access to many major brands and even some exclusives that aren’t available at the big-name stores.
  3. Items purchased from Babylist have a nine-month return window; technically, they say 270 days.
  4. Babylist lets you add unique items to your registry as well. Say you are adopting and would like help with flight and other travel expenses. There are many options for non-traditional gifting. Your friends and family can even sign up to bring you a meal.
  5. Another cool feature is the buying options from different sites and seeing the product prices at multiple stores. This is an excellent way for your gift givers to save a little money while still purchasing something you want. That is a win/win.

The Cons

  1. The gift giver must check the item off of your list after purchase. This can be an extra step that some purchasers miss, leading to duplicate gifts you must return.
  2. Speaking of returns, while Babylist has an extended return window, if a gift comes from another site, you are bound to their return policies. The buyer has to get the receipt to give to the recipient for them to make returns. Unlike many in-store registries, there are a lot of extra steps. It can be unfriendly to the purchaser.

What Are Parents Saying About BabyList?

Check out the Babylist registry reviews if you want to see what parents are saying about it. The Apple App Store has 92,000 reviews and a 4.9 out of 5-star rating. “I hate being tied down to just a few stores when it comes to registering as I like a lot of items from different places. Which is one of the things I love about this app. It lets you search from any store you want and add it to your registry,” one review reads.

Others are not as complimentary while reviewing the Babylist registry. “I did like that you can search for whatever item you want to add from any store and consolidate everything on one complete list. However, it was very difficult for guests to check out, especially if they wanted to buy from multiple sites that were at different stores. They had to checkout for each site separately & also had to pay shipping through EACH site. A lot of people tried to search for items at the same store to avoid this, which would’ve been the same as if I found one store to do my registry.

Top Registry Items

Babylist users want various products, from mirrors to bottles to strollers. There are a lot of baby items out there, and it can be hard to narrow them all down. Babylist published their top registry items in January 2023. Here are the top five.

5. The First Years American Red Cross Deluxe Baby Healthcare and Grooming Kit

The First Years American Red Cross Deluxe Baby Healthcare and Grooming Kit
Register Here

This 17-piece kit has everything from nail clippers to a thermometer and medicine dispenser. These items will keep the baby healthy and neat, and it’s easy for parents to keep it all organized in a zippered pouch.

4. The Sophie the Giraffe Teether

Vulli Sophie the Giraffe Teether
Register Here

This one has been a must-have for parents for years. The soft body and cute cartoon face make Sophie a fan favorite. She is a perfect size and shape for baby and all their teething needs.

3. The FridaBaby Bitty Bundle of Joy

FRIDABABY Bitty Bundle of Joy
Register Here

This has all of the FridaBaby essentials in one kit. It includes the Babylist favorites like the NoseFrida and Windi. It is an excellent gift for any new parent.

2. The Babylist Bottle Box (5 bottles)

BABYLIST Bottle Box (5 Bottles)
Register Here

This is the second most popular product on the list, and for a good reason. It allows parents to try out several bottles to find their baby’s best feeding system. It is great because it will help you to find your favorite before buying an expensive starter set that may not work out.

1. Hatch Rest Sound Machine, Night Light & Time-to-Rise

Babylist Baby Registry Review
Register Here

This number one Babylist registry item creates a customized sleeping environment that can be used for babies and beyond. It helps to develop healthy sleeping habits and control them from your phone. It is one fantastic product! (Read our full review of the Hatch Rest here)

The Final Word

For the most part, Babylist is an excellent registry option. It needs to work out a few kinks to simplify it for the gift giver, but if you are looking for a way to keep all of your registry items in one place and shop efficiently, the Babylist registry is for you. It is also a great way to put unique gifts and experiences on your registry that aren’t available elsewhere. We say give Babylist a try, if for no other reason than to compare prices and get your purchasers the best deal possible so that you and baby are ready to roll.

Was this article helpful?
  • Author

Colleen Dilthey Thomas is a mother of four, three boys and one girl, and a freelance writer. She offers her life experience and a bit of wisdom to a variety… Read more

Subscribe to our newsletter