Our Favorite Products That Help to Increase Your Milk Supply - Baby Chick

Our Favorite Products That Help to Increase Your Milk Supply

breastfeedingPublished December 23, 2020 Opinion

by Nina Spears

The Baby Chick®: Pregnancy, Birth & Postpartum Expert


Affiliate links included. Opinions are our own. Your purchase may earn us a commission, supporting free content. Visit our Chick Picks Shop for more recommended products we love! ❤️

A big decision a mother makes after giving birth to her child is how she wants to feed her baby. If you’ve decided to breastfeed your baby, something else that may be on your mind is whether you’ll produce enough breast milk. Luckily, breastfeeding is a supply/demand system. The more your baby “demands” — meaning, the more that you put your baby to your breast or use your breast pump — the more you’re telling your body to make milk. However, many mothers are still worried about their supply. This is why a lot of mothers actively work for healthy milk production to nourish their children. Thankfully there are some great products available that can help increase your milk supply!

For centuries women have been using herbs to help support healthy lactation and breast milk production. Herbalists call these herbs “galactagogues”—a word derived from Greek, meaning “bringer of milk.”1 Many women have seen a difference after taking these herbs and swear by them. So why not give them a shot?! From one mama to another, here are our favorite products that may help increase your milk supply.

Products That Increase Your Milk Supply

Legendairy Milk

Legendairy Milk

Legendairy Milk provides natural breastfeeding supplements for healthy breast milk production. Their herbal lactation supplements are formulated with carefully chosen ingredients to target the primary issues that affect milk production. I’ve had several doula clients take their supplements, and they have seen a wonderful increase in their milk supply!

Their products are free of any additives or preservatives so that every capsule only contains pure and potent milk-enhancing ingredients. Legendairy Milk said, “We’ve gone to great lengths to ensure our formulations are organic and healthy for both mom and baby because we know a legendairy mom like you deserves a legendairy product.”

  • All of their products are Non-GMO Project Verified.
  • Gluten-Free products — Pump Princess, Milkapalooza, Tea-Tas, Lactivist, and Liquid Sunflower Lecithin
    • They test every batch for gluten to ensure that it is under 10ppm of gluten.
  • Kosher Certified products — Liquid Gold, Pump Princess, Milkaplooza, Cash Cow, Lechita, and Liquid Sunflower Lecithin
  • Soy-free products — Liquid Gold, Pump Princess, Milkapalooza, Cash Cow, Lechita, Sunflower Lecithin, Liquid Sunflower Lecithin, Lactivist (alcohol-free), and Tea-Tas
  • Dairy-free — Don’t let the Legen-dairy fool you! All of their products are all dairy-free.
Legendairy Milk products

Another thing about Legendairy Milk that is interesting is they do NOT contain fenugreek in their supplements. They are the creators of the Fenugreek-free movement. They’ve found that Fenugreek works well to increase breast milk production for some women. For other women, it has no effect or even decreases milk production. It may also cause gassiness/stomach upset in mom and baby, lower blood sugar, cause a maple syrup smell in mom’s sweat and urine, and negatively impact the thyroid hormone. After analyzing the list of potential side effects, Legendairy Milk decided to use alternative herbs.

So which Legendairy Milk products should you try out? The ones that we’ve tested and put our stamp of approval on are their Bestseller Lactation Support Bundle and their Sunflower Lecithin supplements. It’s recommended to try one product at a time for at least 7-10 days to determine what works best for you.

Buy Here

Happy Mama Lactation Cookies

Happy Mama Lactation Cookies

Developed with their in-house team of lactation consultants and registered dietitian nutritionists, Happy Mama Lactation Cookies have key ingredients new moms look for—like oats, brewer’s yeast, & ground flaxseed—PLUS a unique Nutrient Boost Blend™ with DHA to help support breastfeeding moms’ increased nutritional needs during this time.

Happy Mama Lactation Cookies

I’ve tried many lactation bites, cookies, bars, etc., and I have to say, these cookies are some tasty lactation cookies. Normally I can immediately taste the herbs in lactation treats, but these cookies taste like normal cookies! Even my three-year-old approves of them. Haha! The Chocolate, Oat & Sea Salt cookies have the perfect amount of sweetness with a touch of sea salt. So yummy. And the Cinnamon & Oat cookies taste similar to a snickerdoodle, which is one of my favorite cookies!

I really like that these Happy Mama lactation cookies are fenugreek-free and dairy-free, which can be difficult to find. They are made with whole grains and a nutrient boost blend for mother and baby. I love that their company offers parents expert one-on-one feeding support through their Happy Baby Expert program — a free, live chat with their team to help answer questions and provide tips and resources. The Happy Baby Experts provide personalized support on topics including lactation advice, formula feeding, and more. No registration or sign-up required. With Covid-19 making in-person resources difficult to come by, Happy Family is there for families to answer the tough questions.

Buy Here


Motherlove breastfeeding supplements

Motherlove has many different products for expecting and new mothers. The products that they have that can help promote breast milk production are:

More Milk Moringa: *NEW* Motherlove’s newest herbal supplement is specifically created to help support breast milk supply for mothers who have a fenugreek sensitivity or are looking to enhance their supply. This concentrated liquid extract in a vegan capsule delivers a potent combination of galactagogues herbs—moringa, blessed thistle, nettle, and fennel.

This fenugreek-free blend was specially formulated if you:

  • Have a low breast milk supply
  • Wish to increase freezer milk supply stash
  • Need general milk supply support
  • Are looking for a fenugreek alternative

This blend includes the popular superfood herb, moringa, which is known to optimize milk supply and is high in vitamins, minerals, and iron.

More Milk Plus: This is Motherlove’s most popular product and is their best-selling breastfeeding supplement in the US! This supplement contains fenugreek, blessed thistle, nettle, and fennel seed. Many moms find it helps with their supply within 24-48 hours, which is pretty amazing.

Malunggay (Moringa)This is an herb high in iron, protein, vitamins, and minerals and has been used for generations by breastfeeding mothers. It’s widely recommended for breastfeeding and pumping moms who want support and optimization in their milk supply or moms looking to increase their freezer stash. Moringa is also a great fit if you have a sensitivity to the popular herb fenugreek, as this is a fenugreek-free supplement.

Motherlove breastfeeding supplements

Another product of theirs that I love is their award-winning organic nipple cream. It doesn’t help with breast milk production, but it sure does provide relief when you are experiencing sore, cracked, or bleeding nipples.

  • Lanolin-free organic nursing balm
  • Not just for nipples — great as a pump lubricant too
  • Does not need to be wiped off

Breastfeeding and pumping can take a toll on your nipples. This nipple cream can help!

Buy Here

Traditional Medicinals

Traditional Medicinals Organic Pregnancy Women's Tea

Traditional Medicinals is well known for their Mother’s Milk tea. Formulated in 1978, Mother’s Milk is standing strong as America’s #1 lactation tea. It is based on anise, bitter fennel, coriander, and blessed thistle, which are classified as having galactagogue action. Their Mother’s Milk tea blends these herbs for a sweet, slightly bitter, and distinctly licorice taste.

If you’re a breastfeeding mom on-the-go, you should also try their Mother’s Milk bars and chews. They are easy to pack in your purse or pocket and enjoy at a moment’s notice. Whether you choose their teas, bars, or chews, you can rest assure that these herbs have an incredibly rich history of use, tapping into a tradition that’s been passed down to nursing moms for generations.

Buy Here

Power Pumping

Breast pump, water bottle, and Junobie breastmilk storage bags on a kitchen counter

Power pumping is another great option that any breastfeeding mom can do! It doesn’t require any herbs or supplements, just a good breast pump, some water and lactation snacks for you, as well as breast milk storage bags. (We love these from Junobie because they are reusable!)

Power pumping is all about mimicking a cluster feeding but with your breast pump instead. As mentioned earlier, breast milk production works as a supply and demand system. So the more you put your baby or your breast pump to your breasts, the more you are signaling to your body that it needs to make more milk.

To start power pumping, you will need to pump on and off at an interval for an hour. Pick a comfortable place to sit with some water and snacks nearby and get to pumping! Here is how you will pump during the hour:

  • 20 mins on the pump, then resting for 10 minutes
  • 10 mins on the pump, then resting for 1o minutes
  • 10 minutes on the pump

Even if you don’t see any milk coming out during your session, keep pumping! Do this routine once a day for 4-7 days, and your body should respond to the increased demand.

Buy Junobie Bags Here

Final Thoughts

These are our favorite products that can help increase milk supply. However, every woman’s body is unique, so results may vary from mother to mother. There isn’t one lactation product that is guaranteed to work on all women. We all react differently to herbs. Where one product may work wonders for one mother, it may have no impact on another. This is why a little trial and error is necessary so that you can find the right lactation product for your body’s needs. It’s also crucial to determine the root cause of your supply issues if you are dealing with chronic low milk supply.

Also, remember lactation supplements have their place, but they do not replace a qualified lactation consultant’s guidance and expert advice. We highly suggest working with a qualified IBCLC (international board-certified lactation consultant) if you have any breastfeeding issues.

Miranda Kerr breastfeeding her newborn son

Celebrity Moms Share Their Breastfeeding Journey

Mom breastfeeding her baby in the dark. There is a little light in the background.

What Is a Dream Feed and How Can I Do It?

expresed breast milk packed in storage bags and frozen in the freezer, breastfeeding concept

How to Create a Breast Milk Freezer Stash

The Connection Between Postpartum Depression and Breastfeeding – Podcast Ep 114

Mother breastfeeding her baby

Research Shows U.S. Breast Milk is Contaminated by Flame Retardants

Choosing NOT to Breastfeed