The Pros and Cons of the “Cry It Out” Method for Getting a Baby to Sleep

By Quinn Kelly

Marriage & Family Therapist

View All Posts

Quinn Kelly is a busy wife and mother of four boys as well as a marriage and family therapist. She hopes to encourage other moms with laughter and honesty and help remind them that the best part about motherhood has nothing to do with being the “perfect” mom or raising the “perfect” kids, but instead enjoying yourself and your children along the way.
If you like what you are reading and want to hear more from Quinn, follow her personal blog Sanctification and Spitup, which is also found on Facebook.


When I first became a mom, the importance of good sleep wasn’t even on my radar. I remember someone buying me the book, “Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child” by Dr. Marc Weissbluth and telling me that the book had saved her life. I remember feeling like that statement seemed a bit dramatic as I thought to myself, “What’s so complicated about sleep? Babies just eventually learn to do it. Right?”

Ha. Ha. Ha. No. (Not in my case.)


Fast forward 5 months later to a crazy sleep-deprived version of me who had a baby waking up multiple times in the night to nurse who was unable to nap or go to bed on his own without a complicated and semi-ineffective routine of bouncing and nursing, I remember opening up “Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child” (HSHHC) the same book I had earlier disregarded in desperate need of some help.

IMG_4894

But as I read through it and realized Weissbluth’s method involved letting my son cry, I was mad. Actually irate. What kind of idiot thinks it’s smart to let a baby cry to sleep?! So I shelved the book and talked trash on it for the next few months until I once again reached a sleep-deprived breaking point and decided it was time to give it a whirl! And when I officially followed through with it (and lots of prayer) my son started sleeping better than he ever had!

And now as I have continued to have children who have struggled to be good sleepers, I now more than ever see the benefit in encouraging good sleep habits from a young age for both the sake of mom but more importantly BABY!!! (In the last 6 months, I have personally known four babies that were waking 2 to 6 times a night start sleeping 10-12 hour periods after using this method as well as falling asleep on their own!)


baby sleeping

So Just What Is “Cry It Out”?

While the Ferber method involves a parent going in to comfort baby without holding them and progressively adding in more length between comforts, Weissbluth’s method suggests that after the baby is 5-months-old, they are old enough to learn to self soothe. So in the most basic summary of it, Weissbluth’s method says:

  1. Parent develops a soothing bedtime routine where all needs have been met. Baby is clean, freshly diapered and fed.
  2. Parent lays baby down awake even if almost asleep.
  3. Parent leaves room and lets baby cry without going in to reassure. (He believes that by going in to check on or comfort baby you are actually teaching baby that if they cry long enough, you will come instead of teaching them to self soothe and fall asleep.)
  4. At naptime, Weissbluth states that if baby has cried up to an hour, parent can go in and get baby but not soothe them to sleep. Instead, hold baby off until their next nap time. This way baby begins to develop a schedule and realizes that parents will not come and soothe the baby if it fights sleep.
  5. He also states that up until 9 months old, a baby may still need 1-2 feedings in the night and does not prohibit parent from feeding baby in night.

***Disclaimer: Please know this is a paraphrased summary of HSHHC and that in order to actually utilize his method, you should read the book, which offers a wealth of knowledge on everything related to baby’s need for sleep, the research backing it and tips for helping every age of children learn to sleep.

So now that you’ve heard a summary of Weissbluth’s method, here is my list of the pros and cons!

IMG_4893

The Pros of Cry It Out

  • It’s not complicated. The baby cries and learns to self-soothe.
  • Research backs that it works.
  • Even though it feels like listening to crying is actually a year of your life, it normally works within a few days.
  • It can take a horrible sleeper and convert them into a quality sleeper, which Weissbluth teaches can affect their mood and development into childhood.
  • It can stop bad sleep habits from forming while the child is still contained in a crib.
  • It can take a desperate, sleep deprived parent and let them rest.
  • I know more babies that it has worked for than any other method.

The Cons of Cry It Out

  • You have to listen to your baby cry! And nobody enjoys that.
  • Your baby may cry longer than other babies, and it can feel painful. (Some take 15 minutes of low-key crying and they are asleep. Some intensely cry for an hour the first time.)
  • If you progressively form bad habits again (nursing them to sleep and laying them down), you may notice you have to do the process again.
  • It may not eliminate all crying. Once your baby has begun sleeping, they may immediately sleep and never cry again or your baby may have to cry for a few minutes before bed each night or at nap to sleep.
  • There is a possibility that it may not work for your baby.
READ MORE
5 Life Lessons our Grandmothers Knew (And We Should Learn Too)

I am not promoting this method for everyone. Some people have no problem getting up with their child throughout the night and the trade-off of sleeping versus letting a child cry is not worth it. And for that person, this method IS NOT for you. But, for the person who IS struggling to survive on no sleep that has a cranky baby that isn’t taking good naps or sleeping at night, I would suggest trying this method.

And here’s a final reason why from Mary who recently used it: “Cry it out was like ripping off a band-aid. We could have dragged out sleep-training for months, but my ability to work was suffering. Not to mention, baby didn’t know how to transition back to sleep through sleep cycles so he was only taking 20-minute naps, which left him exhausted! We were ALL exhausted day and night. It wasn’t easy, but by night two, our baby slept through the night. We were all rested and happier. It’s just like taking off those training wheels for the first time. It’s scary, but the ability to get a good night’s sleep is so important for baby.”

IMG_4898

Cheers to Finding a Method for Sleep that Works Well for Baby and You!

XOXO-QUIN

Shares

Also on Baby Chick

2 thoughts on “The Pros and Cons of the “Cry It Out” Method for Getting a Baby to Sleep

  1. I have a 4 month old baby, and he is able to self soothe himself to sleep for naps and bedtime. We are still feeding him once during the night. We started sleep training around 3 months, and he adapted quickly. I guess were are pretty lucky.

    1. That’s awesome! Sounds like the routine you guys are doing is working great for your baby. Congrats to y’all! Hoping that things continue going this well. Thanks for commenting! xo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *