The Unique Challenge of Understanding My Middle Child - Baby Chick

The Unique Challenge of Understanding My Middle Child

ParentingUpdated October 12, 2021


Middle children… need I say more? It seemed my middle child revealed herself as such before her baby sister had even arrived. Scientists say birth order plays a part in personality development, but not necessarily in how you would think. Personality does not hinge solely on whether a child is born first or fifth. Instead, they say, it’s the roles siblings adopt that lead to differences in behavior. And as parents, we tend to enforce these roles, whether we realize it or not.

Middle children can be a little more challenging to label. This is because their personalities emerge in response to how they perceive themselves in relation to the next oldest sibling, birth order experts say. Middle children are usually the opposite of an older sibling in temperament and behavior (but not always), and they tend to be the most independent. If the older child is a parent-pleaser, you can almost bet your middle child will rebel for attention. To a middle child, it seems older siblings reap all the rewards, and the baby gets away with murder. Because of this, the middle child will more than likely become an expert negotiator.

Middle children may also gravitate towards friends over family because they often feel left out. As parents, it can be helpful to recognize and respect their need for peers — create opportunities in which your middle child can meet new friends, whether through play dates, school, or church. Middle children sometimes feel like they always have to share their parents — carve out a special time for your middle child to make her feel special. Heck, why not do this for all of your children?

Middle children

My middle child Emma Kate is brave, almost to a fault. She is constantly running into walls, falling (sometimes over her own feet), jumping off of things she shouldn’t be, climbing higher than she should, and generally risky, pushing the limits behavior. While we celebrate her individuality and fearlessness — traits to be admired, no doubt — sometimes I worry that Emma Kate will hurt herself; she is constantly covered in bruises and “ouchies.” What if my middle child’s independence turns out to be destructive?

Emma Kate is a fiercely independent two-year-old. Her favorite phrase of late is “I do it myself.” She wants to do everything her big sister does. And like most toddlers, she does not like to hear “no.” When big sister started school, I had to drag Emma Kate, kicking and screaming, away from the classroom’s open door. And then she cried all the way home. This happened every single day for a year. Did I mention she can be stubborn?

Middle children
Emma Kate couldn’t understand why she couldn’t dance with her sister and the other big girls. So she threw herself down on the floor.

Emma Kate is brilliant. She has learned a lot from watching her big sister, which terrifies me when they are teenagers. (There will be one year of our lives when all three of our girls are in high school at the same time. Lord, help us. I predict we will drink a lot of booze during this year.) Emma Kate loves spending time with us, but it has to be on her terms. She is much less likely to sit and snuggle during an entire movie, so when she is in the mood for snuggles, we soak them up as we might never see that side of her again.

We love our middle child to the moon and back, and we are pretty sure she loves us too, except when she gives us her angriest middle child sneer. You know what I’m talking about. Then we either leave her alone or bribe her with chocolate. Whatever it takes. 😉 Every day with a middle child is an adventure. One we wouldn’t change for the world.

Middle children

What a blessing to have the opportunity to parent three beautifully unique baby girls. I am sure you all feel the same way about your own middle children, even on the hard days. Our job will never be boring, that I can promise you. The world needs more middle children. They are one part beloved and another part bewildering.

Mother combing daughter's hair at home

What Is Permissive Parenting? Pros and Cons

Sad Caucasian Girl Trying to Stop Nose Bleeding using Paper Tissue Side

What a Bloody Nose in Kids Means and How To Treat It

Portrait of cute crying toddler boy. He's in the living room.

Avoiding Toddler Tantrums at Bedtime

A young Latin American woman helps a two year old girl use the jungle gym at the playground on a warm sunny afternoon.

Navigating the Playground with Your Child

Mom breastfeeding her baby in the dark. There is a little light in the background.

What Is a Dream Feed and How Can I Do It?

A girl with a wide smile lies on a carpet of red and yellow leaves in an autumn park.

60 Fall Activities For Kids That Everyone Can Enjoy