Vaginal Birth vs. Cesarean Birth: Which Is Right for You? - Baby Chick

Vaginal Birth vs. Cesarean Birth: Which Is Right for You?

Are you hoping for a vaginal or cesarean birth? Which one is right for you? Here, we break down the pros and cons of each type of delivery.

Updated July 17, 2023

by Ashley Derderian Sousa

Labor & Delivery Nurse, BSN, RN, IBCLC

There is no “right” way to have a baby. Whether you have a vaginal birth or cesarean birth, I always say — all birth is birth, and all birth is beautiful! Some mamas have a preference regarding how they birth their babies. Some want a vaginal birth, while others want a cesarean birth. Of course, it’s always recommended to talk with your healthcare provider about these options, what they mean, and how it pertains to your pregnancy.

While you may have a preference, sometimes, medical situations may supersede them. Your safety and the safety of your baby are what comes first! There are some pros and cons to each of these options, so let’s discuss what they are.

Vaginal Birth vs. Cesarean Birth

Knowing the facts is essential when discussing whether a vaginal or cesarean birth suits you. As a labor, delivery, and postpartum nurse, I have seen probably thousands of births, and they’re all beautiful! However, there are some critical differences between the two.

Cesarean Birth (C-Section)

In 2021, the CDC came out with birth data that found the cesarean birth rate in the United States increased to 32.1%.1 Some cesarean births are planned, some are unplanned, and others are emergencies. That being said, there are some pros to having a cesarean birth.

Pros of C-Section

If it is a planned C-section, one perk is knowing the day and time you’ll get to meet your precious baby. This allows for proper planning to have the best cesarean experience and can be much more predictable than labor and vaginal birth.

For mamas with severe anxiety, having a planned cesarean birth can change how you experience your delivery. It may give you a sense of control in a situation where we don’t have much control, which can be super helpful for some. In an unplanned cesarean, having a life-saving procedure can ensure that mom and baby are healthy and safe.8

Women who have a cesarean birth may also be less likely to experience stress urinary incontinence after delivery and suffer from vaginal tears and hemorrhoids.2

Lastly, cesarean birth decreases the baby’s chances of birth injuries, such as asphyxia (oxygen deprivation), shoulder dystocia, and fractures.7

Cons of C-Section

There are, however, cons that come with having a cesarean birth. There’s often a lack of acknowledgment that cesarean birth is major abdominal surgery. With that comes an increase in the risk of postpartum complications. These complications range from physical symptoms (such as increased bleeding and pain, surgical infections, and blood clots) to emotional health symptoms (such as increased postpartum depression and bonding interference due to less frequent direct contact with the baby after delivery).3 This is not to scare you but to educate you on the facts!

After a cesarean birth, your hospital stay may also be a bit longer. This is because your healthcare providers will want to monitor you more closely and ensure your recovery is headed in the right direction. They also want to ensure you feel confident caring for yourself and your baby before going home. After a cesarean birth, doctors recommend not lifting anything heavier than your baby, which can be challenging for moms caring for other children at home.9

I also like to mention that once there is an incision in the uterus, it can affect subsequent pregnancies and births.8 However, this doesn’t mean that a VBAC (vaginal birth after cesarean) isn’t an option down the road. Once again, discuss your options with your healthcare provider, and they will be able to add educational information that applies to you.

Vaginal Birth

Approximately 68.3% of deliveries are vaginal births.4 Many women prefer to have a vaginal birth. But, due to medical complications or safety concerns, your baby may be born another route. So, always keep an open mind and remember: nothing will matter once that sweet baby is in your arms!

Pros of Vaginal Birth

The pros of a vaginal birth include fewer postpartum complications and an easier or faster recovery. Not to mention your hospital stay may be shorter, which tends to be a significant perk for mamas, especially if you have older children at home. There is also less potential for complications with future pregnancies.10

Additionally, some research shows that breastfeeding success is higher after vaginal birth. This is because having an initial latch within that first hour of life is important for breast milk production and bonding.5 If you’re hoping to breastfeed, no matter your delivery route, tell your care team so they can coordinate appropriately!

And, as crazy as this sounds, if your baby is born vaginally, they are also exposed to healthy bacteria that can boost your newborn’s immune system.6

Cons of Vaginal Birth

Though statistically safer, vaginal birth can increase your risk of some injuries. These include perineal tears or lacerations, pelvic floor injuries or prolapse, urinary incontinence, and hemorrhoids.12,13

Also, the labor and birth process can be exhausting, affecting how you start your journey into parenthood. Most parents may not sleep much after the labor and birth process. Some can suffer from severe fatigue, which can cause a cascade of events and symptoms.11

Further, there are some situations (a woman has a large baby, small pelvis, or long labor) when the baby may be at an increased risk of birth injuries.14 These can include shoulder dystocia, bone fractures, scalp injuries from vacuum extraction, or oxygen deprivation.6

This information may come as a shock or be frightening, but it is meant to give you the tools you need for your delivery. Being adequately informed helps you advocate for yourself. This enables you to ask the right questions and make decisions you’re comfortable with! In a non-emergent situation, don’t be afraid to stand up for yourself and inquire about your options. Educating yourself in the birth process is the first step to empowering yourself through motherhood. This means knowing all the available choices, methods, and techniques!

View Sources +
Was this article helpful?
  • Author
Ashley Derderian Sousa Labor & Delivery Nurse, BSN, RN, IBCLC
  • Social

Ashley Derderian Sousa, RN, IBCLC, is a registered nurse and a board-certified lactation consultant with 12 years of experience, spending the past 8 of those years providing care as a… Read more

A beautiful multiracial pregnant woman rests agains pillows on a hospital bed in the delivery room and does breathing exercises during labor contractions.

Breathing Techniques for Labor and How They Help

What is Vernix and Why is it All Over My Newborn?

What Is Vernix and Why Is It All Over My Newborn?

A new Mother holds her infant to her chest as they bond skin-to-skin in the comfort of their own home. The baby is wearing a diaper and both have their eyes closed as they rest peacefully.

What is Orgasmic Birth? The Best-Kept Birth Secret – Podcast Ep 121

Vocal Toning in Labor: Why Do Women Moan in Childbirth?

Profile view of a multiracial woman wearing a hospital gown standing in her hospital room while affectionately holding and lovingly admiring her newborn baby as he sleeps.

14 Things I Wish I Knew Before My Labor Experience

Woman in labour on a yoga ball in the hospital

Hospital Items You Can Use in Labor That You Didn’t Know About